Total Points: 42%Rating: ‘Hostile Campus’Click here to learn more details about this rating and rubric |
|
Institutional Policies Indicator |
Point Deduction |
Islamophobia and anti-Muslim bias included in anti-discrimination policy |
None |
No adoption of IHRA definition or similar definitions to target activists |
None |
Biased statements/actions: Panel on Palestinian rights cancelled |
-5pts |
Major policy changes/excluding input from students/faculty |
-5pts |
Total Institutional Policies Points |
-10pts |
Student Experience and Campus Climate Indicator |
Point Deduction |
Listed on Islamophobia Tracker |
None |
Petitions or letters posted online alleging discrimination |
-5pts |
-3pts |
|
Media documentation of reported threats targeting students |
-5pts |
Verifiable social media posts |
-5pts |
Total Student Experience and Campus Climate Points |
-18pts |
Civil Rights and Legal Action Indicator |
Point Deduction |
Title VI violations filed with U.S. Dept of Ed Office of Civil Rights |
-10pts |
Lawsuit filed for discrimination against protestors |
None |
Automatic if OCR/DOJ/State finds discrimination – not yet |
None |
Total Civil Rights and Legal Action Points |
-10pts |
Free Speech and Political Expressions Indicator |
Point Deduction |
-10pts |
|
-10pts |
|
Surveillance or spying |
None |
Automatic if release of visa info or compliance with ICE/FBI/DHS |
None |
Total Free Speech and Political Expressions Points |
-20pts |
TOTAL POINTS EARNED BY TULANE UNIVERSITY |
42% OUT OF 100% |
Tulane claims a commitment “to creating and sustaining an environment in which we welcome and practice the free exchange of ideas, the critical examination and discussion of them, and respect the dignity and freedom of others.” Yet, Tulane has persistently met students of diverse backgrounds with discrimination, harassment, and even police violence for protesting Israeli apartheid, occupation, and genocide against the Palestinian people in Gaza. Tulane University’s Arabic Club and the Tulane chapter of Students for A Democratic Society filed a Title VI anti-Palestinian discrimination complaint to the U.S. Department of Education’s Office for Civil Rights in July 2024. According to the complaint, Tulane Arabic Club members were made to remove their keffiyehs before performing at a Tulane Language Day event, and an administrator made a student publicly identify herself as Palestinian on stage. Tulane received a failing score of 36.0 out of 100 in the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression’s (FIRE) 2025 College Free Speech Rankings, revealing a stark contradiction between its stated values and its actual practices. Tulane has criminalized students participating in non-violent demonstrations, suspended student groups organizing for Palestinian human rights on campus, and wrongfully punished students without the jurisdiction to do so, all in contradiction to their freedom of expression commitments.
In February 2024, over 100 Tulane community members signed a letter expressing their concerns regarding anti-Palestinian rhetoric after Tulane University reportedly canceled a panel organized by students that was intended to feature lawyers and legal experts discussing how people who speak up for Palestinian rights are being punished. The event was planned as part of Civil Rights Law Week and followed all the steps to obtain approval. But at the last minute, the university shut it down and falsely claimed that the students themselves had canceled it. This is part of a larger pattern at Tulane of silencing voices that support Palestine. By blocking a peaceful, educational event, the university is sending a clear message: students who speak out for Palestinian rights aren’t welcome.
On April 30, 2024, Louisiana State Police reportedly showed up in riot gear at an encampment, forcing demonstrators off campus, arresting fourteen individuals, and reportedly pointing weapons at peaceful protestors. The Tulane administration reportedly suspended five students and the Tulane chapter of Students for a Democratic Society (SDS). In response, students and faculty alike criticized the university for its handling of the situation, only to be met with silence. On May 3, 2024, 852 graduate and undergraduate students signed a letter to President Michael Fitts and the Tulane administration demanding an apology for the handling of the protests and false narrative portraying the protests as violent, citing nine other instances of anti-Palestinian discrimination on campus, and requesting protection from such discrimination in the future. In September 2024, a judge acquitted the protesters, and all charges were dropped.
Tulane faculty members publicly expressed their opposition to the university’s response to student protests. 200 Tulane faculty members signed a letter to President Fitts opposing his escalation of the protests through deployment of police, the arrests and suspensions of students, and the “efforts to intimidate students and employees by threatening retaliatory action for participation in peaceful protests.” According to a video shared on the Instagram account of Assistant Professor Andrew McDowell, at least four staff members were reportedly placed on administrative leave for simply attending the protests. Over a dozen professors spoke in the video, stating that the protests were peaceful until the police began to escalate and condemning the university for threatening faculty who participated in protesting genocide. Tulane has demonstrated that when it comes to standing for the human rights of Palestinians, such expression will only be met with punishment and criminalization, whether it be students or faculty.
In March 2025, the Tulane administration reportedly pursued further disciplinary action against several students who reorganized into a different group off campus known as the Together United Students for a Democratic Society. Although they were operating under a new name and location, the students were subsequently penalized for protesting Mahmoud Khalil’s ICE detention, including semester-long suspensions. In response, FIRE wrote a letter to the university administrators urging them to drop the charges and validating that Tulane raised “serious due process concerns.” On June 9th, the students announced that all charges against them were dropped. Yet, as an institution of higher education, Tulane appears to have failed to uphold its standards of free speech and has not met its obligations to protect all its students from discrimination.
A group of Tulane students issued a public letter denouncing the university’s alarming crackdown on peaceful advocacy for Palestinian human rights. Tulane University has fostered an environment of fear, retaliation, and institutional bias against students and faculty who speak out against genocide. Through police crackdowns, organizational suspensions, academic retaliation, and the criminalization of peaceful protest, Tulane has made clear that anti-genocide expression will not be tolerated. Its administration has failed to uphold its stated commitments to free speech, human rights, and academic freedom; instead, it has chosen to punish dissent and protect complicity. Therefore, CAIR formally designates Tulane University a ‘Hostile Campus’ for anti-genocide students.